Tamara Lynn Chambers

Dolores

Doug Walker

Nostalgia Critic

Malcolm Ray

Contestant #1

Brett Bonynge

Contestant #2

Robbie Allen

Bob

Alyssa Jackson

Barbara

Paul Rohan

Ben

Jimmy Melf

Reilly

Harry Locke IV

Julio

Jim Jarosz

Rolly the Fox/Practitioner

Heather Reusz

Atlantis Somerset

Nick La Banca

Nautical Nineties Narrator

Justin Hoffman

"Spin My Helm" Singer

McKane Searle

"Spin My Helm" Bassist

James Banasiak

"Spin My Helm" Drummer

Alexis Banasiak

Waving Woman 1

Mooog

Waving Woman 2

Rob Scallon

Waving Man

Catheryn Kuhar

Sailor Girl

Danny Grenchik

"Shark Weak" Singer

Trevor Casterline

"Poop Deck Peck" Harmony 1

Tom Reusz

"Poop Deck Peck" Harmony 2

Aiyanna Wade

Wife

Steve Davis

Husband

Joe Banasiak

Old Man

Jim Banasiak

Skeleton