Dennis L.A. White

Chris Walker

Charles Durning

Kris Kringle

Arthur Colombino

Jesus Christ

Tony Todd

God

Wilson Jermaine Heredia

Satan

Donna Bostany

Christie

Maribeth Mooney

Virgin Mary

Alison Whitney

Mary Magdalene

Ken Del Vecchio

Mario Vigilante

S.J. Hannah

Black Jesus

Anthony Cumberbatch Jr.

Elf

Sean Allison

Elf

Blanche Baker

Delores Kelly

Michael Boatman

Walter Wayne

Matt Ballard

Dennis

Allegra Cohen

Robin

Keith Collins

Troy

Heather Bunch

Hot Girl

Sara Christal

Hot Girl

Crystal Rolon

Hot Girl

Anthony Falco

Judge Milton

Frank Gigante

Court Officer

Penny Flick

Susie

Armen Garo

Pop

Randy Jones

R.J.

Molly Leland

Julia

Nicol Paone

Patti Kelly

Rachael Robbins

Jessie

Daniel Mesrobian

George the Cowboy

Erika Smith

Sonya