Brandon Flynn

Max

Julia Goldani Telles

Alex

Ki Hong Lee

Dan

Annie Mumolo

Jan

Peter Scolari

Paul

Priscilla Lopez

Esther

Susan James Berger

Rosemary

Monique Kim

Yu Shen

Lindsay Mushett

Dan's date

Tom Proctor

Vin

Mick O'Rourke

Blind Man

Jude Washock

Movie Patron/Valencia's Friend

Tiffany Milian

Erica

Natalie Paige Goldberg

Nurse

Anthony Traina

Wombat

Diana Ruppe

Officer Suzie Mae

Jon Peterson

Colin Clive

Danny Reuben

Clinic Nurse

Tim Simon

Waiter

Rhaechyl Walker

Valencia

Sea McHale

Craig

Kendra Kirby

Myrtle

Alexander Low

Pizza Delivery Guy

Lucia Giannetta

Debbie

Shari Abdul

Burn Nurse

Natalie Paige Goldberg

Hospital Nurse

Sarah Litzsinger

New Therapist

Michael Callahan

Hospital Doctor (uncredited)

James A. Pierce III

Hospital Nurse 1 (uncredited)

Mary Scarpello

Movie Patron (uncredited)

Ashley Szczerbacki

Movie Patron / Student (uncredited)

Allen Wall

Juror #1 (uncredited)

Kevin A. Wall

Paramedic (uncredited)